I received an email this week asking whether BENA Capital has completely moved away from investing in multifamily real estate. The short answer is: No. We are not abandoning multifamily real estate. We are just becoming way more selective about where, when, and how we invest in it.
The long answer is: There is an important distinction between losing confidence in multifamily as an asset class and being less willing to purchase properties at current prices. While we continue to view multifamily housing as an attractive long-term investment, in recent years, we are approaching the sector with considerably more caution – becoming even more selective about individual properties and markets.
One reason is that we have see an oversupply of apartment buildings – especially in Sun Belt markets, including parts of Texas, Florida, Arizona, and the Carolinas. The resulting supply has put pressure on rental rates and occupancy in markets where new development continue to exceed the growth in renter demand. Other regions with constrained new supply and steadier rental conditions remain comparatively attractive, though property-level economics, market stability, municipal objectives, employment/population trends, local supply, and acquisition pricing continue to be the most important criteria when evaluating any BENA Capital acquisition.
Another reason is that we are seeing a more normalized rental market. In many locations, landlords are offering concessions to attract tenants. This affects effective rental income, and ultimately property valuations. Combined with a marked increase in the cost of insurance, property taxes, maintenance, labor, and utilities, even when rental income remains stable, these increasing operating expenses can eat away at net operating income.
Despite these challenges, multifamily has several characteristics that continue to be attractive. Housing is a fundamental necessity. People need somewhere to live regardless of broader economic conditions. Renting remains financially necessary for many households. High home prices, mortgage rates, and affordability constraints can sustain rental demand. In some strategic locations, population growth and migration can support long-term rental housing demand.
Multifamily real estate is still attractive long-term, but buying at the right valuation is particularly important in today’s environment. We are not necessarily moving away from multifamily. We are moving away from aggressive valuations, speculative development, and markets where supply has outpaced demand.
Our fund strategy for the Mosaic Fund served us well: we acquired value-add multifamily properties for below market prices using all-cash offers, operated efficiently, and delivered stable cash flow. But sell discipline just as important, and is one of the core components of BENA Capital’s conservative capital strategy and risk-management framework. In 2023, based on our analysis, we determined that it was a prime opportunity to capitalize on the portfolio’s gains. Over the course of the fund, BENA Capital made 18 consecutive quarters of distributions, paying out over $210,000 in cash flow to our investors and successfully returning all of the original capital invested. In addition to the quarterly dividends, we were pleased to have surpassed the projected appreciation targets for the Mosaic Fund, resulting in a remarkable final distribution of profits: 37.44% Total ROI for our Tier I investors and a 41.02% Total ROI for our Tier II investors.
The opportunity in multifamily real estate today is not in acquiring the most properties. It’s in acquiring the right properties, at the right price, with a capital structure that allows investors to withstand market fluctuations without jeopardizing their long-term financial objectives.
